Page 3 of 4

Re: Slow start: Help me figure this one out...

Posted: Thu Oct 19, 2017 11:51 am
by Geezer
Please keep us posted regarding what you do to fix this. My starter has been exhibiting the same symptoms and I may look into it once the snow flies.

Re: Slow start: Help me figure this one out...

Posted: Thu Oct 19, 2017 12:06 pm
by bungie4
Aw, it's okay Marty, lots of guys start slow, but they finish strong!

Re: Slow start: Help me figure this one out...

Posted: Fri Oct 20, 2017 6:37 pm
by 0face
It was definitely the starter. It start so lively now! A few Viagra in the gas tank and all good!

Re: Slow start: Help me figure this one out...

Posted: Sat Oct 21, 2017 9:45 am
by Bust
0face wrote: Fri Oct 20, 2017 6:37 pm It start so lively now! A few Viagra in the gas tank and all good!
Wow..
Nice job gaying up your post. :lol:

Good to see ya got it fxd.

Re: Slow start: Help me figure this one out...

Posted: Sat Oct 21, 2017 2:44 pm
by wheatonFJR
Bust wrote: Sat Oct 21, 2017 9:45 am
0face wrote: Fri Oct 20, 2017 6:37 pm It start so lively now! A few Viagra in the gas tank and all good!
Wow..
Nice job gaying up your post. :lol:

Good to see ya get fxd.
???!!!

Re: Slow start: Help me figure this one out...

Posted: Sat Oct 21, 2017 3:57 pm
by raYzerman
Save that original starter for forensic analysis........

Re: Slow start: Help me figure this one out...

Posted: Sat Oct 21, 2017 4:57 pm
by ionbeam
raYzerman wrote: Sat Oct 21, 2017 3:57 pm Save that original starter for forensic analysis........
The brushes wear creating a fine, mostly conductive dust. The copper commutator lobes gets lightly worn by the brushes creating a fine conductive copper dust. Oil starts to seep in. The oil, brush dust and copper dust combine into a very thick paste. The paste starts to collect in the kerfs between the commutator lobes. The mostly conductive paste now starts to let current leak between commutator lobes causing excess current draw and simultaneously reduces the current through the energized commutator lobes reducing motor torque. High current draw and slow rotor turning = Marty's slow starting woes.

New seals in the starter ends. Clean, clean, clean the starter. Scrupulously clean the commutator kerfs all the way to the bottom, end to end of the kerf. Polish the commutator lobe surfaces. Reuse the remainder of the brushes (or replace if you really want to). Reload the starter into the bike; ride trouble free for another 100k miles. :D

Re: RE: Re: Slow start: Help me figure this one out...

Posted: Sat Oct 21, 2017 11:40 pm
by silverback
ionbeam wrote:
raYzerman wrote: Sat Oct 21, 2017 3:57 pm Save that original starter for forensic analysis........
The brushes wear creating a fine, mostly conductive dust. The copper commutator lobes gets lightly worn by the brushes creating a fine conductive copper dust. Oil starts to seep in. The oil, brush dust and copper dust combine into a very thick paste. The paste starts to collect in the kerfs between the commutator lobes. The mostly conductive paste now starts to let current leak between commutator lobes causing excess current draw and simultaneously reduces the current through the energized commutator lobes reducing motor torque. High current draw and slow rotor turning = Marty's slow starting woes.

New seals in the starter ends. Clean, clean, clean the starter. Scrupulously clean the commutator kerfs all the way to the bottom, end to end of the kerf. Polish the commutator lobe surfaces. Reuse the remainder of the brushes (or replace if you really want to). Reload the starter into the bike; ride trouble free for another 100k miles. :D
Yup.

Used to have a lathe that was made for cleaning up commutators. Also had a small cutting wheel to clean the insulators between them. Some coarse steel wool to break the glaze on the brushes.

I originally pegged the battery as the culprit. If it were an old Ford 460, you'd expect the starter before anything. This is the first failed starter I have heard of on a FJR. Learn something new everyday!

Re: Slow start: Help me figure this one out...

Posted: Sun Oct 22, 2017 8:31 am
by Geezer
ionbeam wrote: Sat Oct 21, 2017 4:57 pm
raYzerman wrote: Sat Oct 21, 2017 3:57 pm Save that original starter for forensic analysis........
The brushes wear creating a fine, mostly conductive dust. The copper commutator lobes gets lightly worn by the brushes creating a fine conductive copper dust. Oil starts to seep in. The oil, brush dust and copper dust combine into a very thick paste. The paste starts to collect in the kerfs between the commutator lobes. The mostly conductive paste now starts to let current leak between commutator lobes causing excess current draw and simultaneously reduces the current through the energized commutator lobes reducing motor torque. High current draw and slow rotor turning = Marty's slow starting woes.

New seals in the starter ends. Clean, clean, clean the starter. Scrupulously clean the commutator kerfs all the way to the bottom, end to end of the kerf. Polish the commutator lobe surfaces. Reuse the remainder of the brushes (or replace if you really want to). Reload the starter into the bike; ride trouble free for another 100k miles. :D
That sounds like the way to go for a frugal person like myself.

Re: Slow start: Help me figure this one out...

Posted: Sun Oct 22, 2017 8:47 am
by raYzerman
I had a fellow firefighter buddy back in the day who was a motor rebuilder. Took my vacuum cleaner motor to him, he cleaned up the comm with the lathe, reassembled, fired it up and used an abrasive stick on the comm to bed in the brushes. It was amazing to hear the increase in speed as the brushes became perfectly matched to the comm. Of course, not possible on a closed in set of brushes on a starter motor.

I have seen postings on other forums (not many) where the end seal let a lot of oil seep in and clog up the comm area. Marty's is mild compared to those that were totally gunked up. Usually with higher mileage bikes.

Bring the old one to the next tech day, Marty!

Re: Slow start: Help me figure this one out...

Posted: Sun Oct 22, 2017 9:36 am
by ionbeam
It is very, very rare for such a young starter to fail. It seems that oil sealing is the root of all evil :twisted:

Any good Man Hack has to have some element of danger. The armature can be chucked in a drill in a horizontal position with the far end in a V-block, then use a mild file to make a poor mans 'lathe'. You aren't cutting down the commutator much, just smoothing the surface.

Re: RE: Re: Slow start: Help me figure this one out...

Posted: Sun Oct 22, 2017 10:18 am
by silverback
ionbeam wrote:It is very, very rare for such a young starter to fail. It seems that oil sealing is the root of all evil :twisted:

Any good Man Hack has to have some element of danger. The armature can be chucked in a drill in a horizontal position with the far end in a V-block, then use a mild file to make a poor mans 'lathe'. You aren't cutting down the commutator much, just smoothing the surface.
That could work well. Possibly even some emery cloth.

This reminds me of Galaxy Quest where they asked Tim Allen's character if he could make a rudimentary lathe while trying to fight off a space creature made of large rocks.

This just happens to be the movie where Sigourney Weaver was a blonde in a push up, which was the best part of that movie.Image

Re: Slow start: Help me figure this one out...

Posted: Sun Oct 22, 2017 10:21 am
by 0face
silverback wrote:
ionbeam wrote:It is very, very rare for such a young starter to fail. It seems that oil sealing is the root of all evil :twisted:

Any good Man Hack has to have some element of danger. The armature can be chucked in a drill in a horizontal position with the far end in a V-block, then use a mild file to make a poor mans 'lathe'. You aren't cutting down the commutator much, just smoothing the surface.
That could work well. Possibly even some emery cloth.

This reminds me of Galaxy Quest where they asked Tim Allen's character if he could make a rudimentary lathe while trying to fight off a space creature made of large rocks.

This just happens to be the movie where Sigourney Weaver was a blonde in a push up, which was the best part of that movie.Image
Somehow I understand this thought process...


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Re: Slow start: Help me figure this one out...

Posted: Sun Oct 22, 2017 11:28 am
by Cav47
Why am I NOT surprised that a technical post about Marty's starter (immediately upon completion) has morphed into a boob picture! It did take 3 pages, so should I be depressed or impressed? Lol.

Good to hear your equipment is back up to full speed!

Re: RE: Re: Slow start: Help me figure this one out...

Posted: Sun Oct 22, 2017 11:35 am
by silverback
Cav47 wrote:Why am I NOT surprised that a technical post about Marty's starter (immediately upon completion) has morphed into a boob picture! It did take 3 pages, so should I be depressed or impressed? Lol.

Good to hear your equipment is back up to full speed!
You've heard of Godwyn's law? Well on this forum, it's just a bit different.

Image Image Image

Re: RE: Re: RE: Re: Slow start: Help me figure this one out...

Posted: Sun Oct 22, 2017 12:42 pm
by NTXFJR
silverback wrote:
Cav47 wrote:Why am I NOT surprised that a technical post about Marty's starter (immediately upon completion) has morphed into a boob picture! It did take 3 pages, so should I be depressed or impressed? Lol.

Good to hear your equipment is back up to full speed!
You've heard of Godwyn's law? Well on this forum, it's just a bit different.

Image Image Image
Boobs in push up bra and Marty's equipment is back up now. Makes total sense.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G930A using Tapatalk


Re: Slow start: Help me figure this one out...

Posted: Mon Oct 23, 2017 1:30 pm
by Uncle Hud
Her sexiest role, IMHO, because the Alien movies were too scary to watch.

Re: RE: Re: Slow start: Help me figure this one out...

Posted: Mon Oct 23, 2017 1:45 pm
by wheatonFJR
silverback wrote: Sun Oct 22, 2017 10:18 am
ionbeam wrote:It is very, very rare for such a young starter to fail. It seems that oil sealing is the root of all evil :twisted:

Any good Man Hack has to have some element of danger. The armature can be chucked in a drill in a horizontal position with the far end in a V-block, then use a mild file to make a poor mans 'lathe'. You aren't cutting down the commutator much, just smoothing the surface.
That could work well. Possibly even some emery cloth.

This reminds me of Galaxy Quest where they asked Tim Allen's character if he could make a rudimentary lathe while trying to fight off a space creature made of large rocks.

This just happens to be the movie where Sigourney Weaver was a blonde in a push up, which was the best part of that movie.Image
Alan/ionbeam was JUST going to go there...

Re: RE: Re: Slow start: Help me figure this one out...

Posted: Mon Oct 23, 2017 2:35 pm
by ionbeam
wheatonFJR wrote: Mon Oct 23, 2017 1:45 pm
silverback wrote: Sun Oct 22, 2017 10:18 am
ionbeam wrote:It is very, very rare for such a young starter to fail. It seems that oil sealing is the root of all evil :twisted:

Any good Man Hack has to have some element of danger. The armature can be chucked in a drill in a horizontal position with the far end in a V-block, then use a mild file to make a poor mans 'lathe'. You aren't cutting down the commutator much, just smoothing the surface.
That could work well. Possibly even some emery cloth.

This reminds me of Galaxy Quest where they asked Tim Allen's character if he could make a rudimentary lathe while trying to fight off a space creature made of large rocks.

This just happens to be the movie where Sigourney Weaver was a blonde in a push up, which was the best part of that movie.
Alan/ionbeam was JUST going to go there...
Actually, Galaxy Quest was poking fun at Star Trek where Captain Kirk used some found mineral deposits, a few stray large diamonds and a hollow log to construct a cannon to shoot bad, bad antagonist Gorn.

Image

Now, any good FJRider can troubleshoot and fix his FJR in the pouring rain, at night using a removed tail light as a volt meter to diagnose and replace a failed stator while using only the tool kit from under the seat. Easy. Until Sigourney Weaver in her push up stops to watch -- totally vacating the FJRider's ability to think or reason out the problem at hand.

Re: Slow start: Help me figure this one out...

Posted: Mon Oct 23, 2017 2:39 pm
by wheatonFJR
^^^
spoken like the true tech wizard that he is.